⚽Arsenal vs Manchester City

Presented by Once Sport

⚽Arsenal vs Manchester City

Today we take a closer look at the fascinating duel between Arsenal and Manchester City. What stood out most: Pep Guardiola seems to be evolving. The perfectionist is becoming more pragmatic – but is that a sign of strength or a sign of necessity?

The Numbers Don’t Lie

Before diving into the game itself, a few remarkable stats:

• Arteta’s winning formula: Mikel Arteta is the first coach to go five league matches unbeaten against Guardiola (2 wins, 3 draws).

• City’s poor start: Just 7 points from their first 5 games – City’s worst start to a season since 2006/07 under Stuart Pearce.

• Possession shocker: City’s 32.8% possession was the lowest ever in a league match under Guardiola.

These figures tell a clear story: the master of possession football was outsmarted by his former assistant.

Arsenal’s Midfield Masterclass

Arsenal operated in a fluid 3-2-2-3 structure from Zone 2. The key? The midfield “box” wasn’t static – it was constantly rotating. Sometimes Calafiori (tucking in as an inverted full-back) and Merino formed the double pivot, with Rice higher up. At other times, Trossard drifted into the half-space, Rice dropped deeper, and Calafiori pushed wide.

This constant fluidity left City with unsolvable problems. Guardiola’s men defended in a classic 4-4-2 zonal block, but the distances between the lines were often too large. Arsenal repeatedly exploited the gaps in the half-spaces.

City’s full-backs were forced into constant dilemmas: step inside to cover midfield, or stay wide to mark the winger? Arsenal thrived on this uncertainty. Bernardo Silva tried to stay close to Rice, but City never pressed with real intensity. That gave Arsenal’s back three plenty of time to recycle possession and pick their moments to play forward.

These two sequences perfectly illustrate the problems City faced on the day.

City’s “+1” Defensive Approach

One notable feature of City’s defending was their plus-one strategy in the back line. Instead of going man-to-man, they always tried to keep one spare defender against Arsenal’s forwards.

But this caution only handed Arsenal more control. The Gunners consistently found numerical superiority in midfield and circulated possession with ease. With City reluctant to press aggressively, Arsenal’s rotations were carried out almost undisturbed, opening up the very spaces City intended to close.

The Missing Rodri Factor

Rodri, usually City’s conductor in midfield, was a non-factor. Arsenal shut down central areas so effectively that City never established their usual passing rhythm. The Spaniard, normally dictating tempo and pulling the strings, was virtually cut out of the game.

Instead, City relied on counter-attacks – like Haaland’s opener. It was a brilliant break, showcasing why the Norwegian is lethal when given space. But it was also telling: City needed to score against the run of play.

Arsenal didn’t panic after going behind. Their defending was compact and aggressive, while City often stayed “near” their men without fully engaging. At this level, those fine margins in duels often decide the outcome.

Presented by Once Sport

Complete Sports Analysis Solution

Once Sport offers user-friendly tools for video analysis, tactical planning, and automated recording. Our integrated ecosystem helps coaches and analysts create professional analysis with ease.

Once Sport Analyser
Advanced video analysis software with automated tracking, 3D animated graphics, and live analysis features. Create professional presentations like you see on TV with powerful tagging options and the quickest workflow in the industry.

Once Sport Coach Board
Your tool for creating drills, training sessions, lineups, and tactical analysis on an easy-to-use 2D board. Build animated scenarios that help players understand tactics instantly.

Once Sport Autocam
Affordable automated recording solution for clubs at all levels. AI-powered software that follows the ball automatically and creates TV-like footage from any camera setup.

Professional sports analysis tools designed for everyone – no hidden costs, no storage limits.

Exclusive for our newsletter subscribers:

Use the promo code "TEAMFUSSBALL10" to get 10% off any Once Sport product.

Start a 14-day free trial (No credit card required)

Guardiola’s Pragmatic Shift

By the end of the first half, City had already dropped deeper, effectively forming a back five. Yet the core issue remained: Arsenal dominated the spaces between the lines.

In the second half, many expected a tactical shake-up. Initially, little changed. Arsenal stayed in control, even if they lacked a bit of creativity without Ødegaard.

Then came Guardiola’s first big adjustment: Ake for Foden, a deliberate move to a back five. A pragmatic call. Sometimes a coach just knows: today, dominance isn’t happening. The opponent controls midfield, and your own blueprint isn’t working. In those moments, stubbornness is weakness – pragmatism is strength. Guardiola could have clung to his possession-first philosophy, but instead he adapted to damage limitation.

The logic was sound: in a 5-4-1, one defender can always step out without leaving the line exposed. That flexibility had been missing in the 4-4-2.

Later, Haaland was withdrawn for González. With the back five already in place, City couldn’t hold the ball for long. They had no breathing space, no sustained phases of control – Arsenal kept pushing. The switch aimed to add midfield stability, with Doku pushed up top to preserve counter-attacking threat.

This was Guardiola adjusting to circumstances: trading possession dominance for structural security. For any coach, the lesson is clear – flexibility often matters more than philosophy.

Goalkeepers Under the Microscope

One subplot summed up the evening: Raya vs. Donnarumma.
Raya’s calmness and precise distribution consistently broke City’s pressing attempts. Donnarumma, in contrast, often resorted to long balls or misplaced passes. His shot-stopping is world-class, but his build-up play exposed City.

That difference tilted possession even further in Arsenal’s favor. While Raya gave Arsenal control, Donnarumma added uncertainty to City’s play.

The Late Equaliser

For long spells, Arsenal dominated possession without carving out clear chances. City’s more physical side dealt well with crosses and second balls. But the one time City pushed higher and held a high line, Arsenal pounced.

Martinelli’s delicate lob for the late 1-1 was the inevitable outcome of Arsenal’s persistence. On balance, the Gunners fully deserved the point. They had dictated most phases of play, only vulnerable when City countered after turnovers.

The Bigger Picture: Guardiola’s Future

Guardiola now has a squad with different profiles – bigger, stronger, more direct in transitions. But the seamless harmony of his earlier sides is missing.

The key question is whether Guardiola can adapt and reinvent himself at City – or whether his time at the club is simply nearing its natural end?

Check out our Homepage for exclusive training videos and products.

Was this post forwarded to you? Subscribe here.

Have an idea or feedback to share? [email protected]